Karavansara

East of Constantinople, West of Shanghai

Diversity in fantasy stories

6 Comments

This post takes its lead from what Unicornblues published on Way Too Fantasy.
Take a minute and please check it out.
Done?
Fine.

Now.

Cover of Weird Tales (November 1935): The feat...I agree absolutely with the fact that given the wide choice of possible settings – historical, psaeudo-historical and completely made up – the matter of diversity in imaginative fiction and in fantasy in particular should be easily settled.
Heroic fantasy and sword & sorcery, in particular, play on elements which include globetrotting, clashing cultures and mixed, bazaar-like settings.
I could simply point at the Hyborian world Robert Howard created, and consider the matter settled.
Howard put Conan through the grinder in a variety of cultural environments, from quasi-Roman Aquilonia to the Harold Lamb-influenced horse tribes of the eastern steppes, all the way to the Black Kingdoms and the native-american-influenced Pictish forests of the north.

Granted, the Cona stories are not the model I would suggest for a multi-ethnical fantasy – but the setting does provide the tools for it.
Our modern sensibilities provide the need, and the spark, so to speak, to tell such stories.

But also, our historical past was much more multi-ethnical than we are normally led to believe.
Vikings raided the Mediterranean shores, the Chinese probably reached North America (and met the Aztecs? Wow! That’s a start for a good story! Or were they the Mayas? Ah, it would be great anyway!)
And obviously the Silk Road (you knew I was heading in this direction!) was a melting pot of cultures, genes, stories – witness the variety and diversity of the so called “Arabian Nights“.
No historical empire worth its name was ever a single-culture, single-ethnicity thing.

But let’s look at the whole thing from another side, shall we?

When I write fiction, everything in my story should be in the service of the story.
So, does diversity serve my story?
I think in most cases the answer is yes.
A well-varied, multi-ethnical or multi-cultural world simplifies a lot of things: it creates conflicts, hints at deep history, provides colour and wonder.
Avoiding such a powerful tool for the sake of some supposed “historical accuracy” is, in my opinion, not very wise.

All in all, using diversity in fantasy does not mean placing tokens in my narrative, but actually using characters and setting to make the texture of my narrative deeper and more satisfactory.
So, why not?

Author: Davide Mana

Paleontologist. By day, researcher, teacher and ecological statistics guru. By night, pulp fantasy author-publisher, translator and blogger. In the spare time, Orientalist Anonymous, guerilla cook.

6 thoughts on “Diversity in fantasy stories

  1. “A well-varied, multi-ethnical or multi-cultural world simplifies a lot of things: it creates conflicts, hints at deep history, provides colour and wonder.
    Avoiding such a powerful tool for the sake of some supposed “historical accuracy” is, in my opinion, not very wise.”

    Exactly. 🙂

    Like

  2. Great post. I got in a discussion the other day about how the idea of a ‘lily white’ medieval world is either the product of racists and social darwinists, or politically correct writers who equate European with White and Evil, and has nothing to do with actual European history, what with the Caliphate in Spain, the misciela of Normans and Franks and the descendants of Romans in France, Magna Grecia in Italy, the various Asiatic and Turkic tribes in Magyarorszag and Ukraine and the Balkans and mingling with that mix of Romans and Slavs and other ‘Europeans.’ Character traits should serve the story, and making your hero a left-handed Tajik lesbian Bocce-ball Champion will do nothing to help your story, unless the problems she encounters (or the solutions she comes up with) are born of those traits.

    Like

  3. Pingback: NaNoWriMo and the Diversity in SFF Debate | Way Too Fantasy

  4. Pingback: The Detective with a Funny Hat | Stark Writing Crazy

  5. History is quite clear about ethinc diversity: it’s a ever-present factor, no matter the part of the world we’re talking about. As soon as somebody start to travel out of his village the concept of meeting “diversity” became reality.
    In fiction those who choose (yes, its’ a choice) to erase diversity are telling us just one thing: they do no want diversity in real life. The name of the game became racism.

    Like

  6. Thanks everybody for the comments.
    I think the main problem with political correctedness is, it makes us stop thinking at the problem, it just helps us sweep it under the rug.
    A good, solid, fun story, written to show the marvel and variety of a multicultural world can do much more to help us become better people than any tweak to our language or our narrative for fear of offending someone’s prejudices.

    Like

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.